In the simple attached model, I'm trying to have 2 TEs travel together. One does the picking (Picker) and transfers the parts to the other (Transporter). I have 2 problems:
1 - How can I make the Transporter go right next to the Picker and not in a different aisle like it does? It does that even if I decrease the Node Spacing.
2 - How can I trigger the A* logic to recalc (optimizenetwork) when the model blocks like it does for token #5?
Thanks a lot for any ideas.
I am not able to download your model for some reason. Could you re-post it in a comment?
The nature of A* requires the task executors to avoid each other because they are potential collisions, just like other objects in an A* model. So, fundamentally, you're not going to be able to get the TE to travel close enough that they might collide.
Based on your explanation, however, you want to have the Transporter and the Picker travel together, so we can just put the Picker inside the Transporter and then move objects into it as we would a trailer or an operator pushing a cart. This is essentially the same functionality, although it will look a little different.
Please review my attached model and let me know what you think. Like I said, it's not going to be aesthetic, but it is functional.
Thanks for the idea. It solves part of the problem.
But, they don't go in the same aisle where the product is. They go to the next aisle. I had this problem in my version with the Transporter but, at least, my Picker went into the correct aisle. Now they both go into the wrong aisle.
Any way to make them go in to the correct aisle?
Glad that it helped partially solve the problem, @Patrick Cloutier.
I looked at why this was happening and it appears that the A* logic will try and get as close as it can to the item using the shortest route possible. I attached a version of the model with wider aisles and you'll notice the same behavior; the AGV is in the "correct" aisle, but not exactly the same grid space (in the y dimension) as the box.
In the case of the first couple of boxes in your model, the shortest route means going to the grid space next to the box rather than directly in front of it. This is just part of how A* works. If you're looking for a specific pickup point, it might be to your benefit to use an AGV network so there's more control and less ambiguity over the pickup/dropoff locations.
@Matthew Gillespie may have more to add regarding A*, but I think you're going to have more control using AGVs.
I am evaluating the different methods to help a client. And it's now clearer and clearer that AGV is the way to go. Thanks a lot,
@Patrick Cloutier if you use a Travel To Location task activity they will move down the correct aisle. This changes how the navigator calculates the travel path to the item. I've attached Tanner's model with that change.
AGV may be a better way to go, alternatively you can add more process flow logic to better control how the te's travel. For instance, figure out which direction the te is facing. Then do a travel task to the end of the aisle in the forward direction. Then travel to the item.
14 People are following this question.
© 1993- FlexSim Software Products, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FlexSim is a fully 3D simulation software environment. FlexSim can be used to simulate any process in any industry.
FlexSim®, FlexSim Healthcare™, Problem Solved.®, the FlexSim logo, the FlexSim X-mark, and the FlexSim Healthcare logo with stylized Caduceus mark are trademarks of FlexSim Software Products, Inc. All rights reserved.
