FloWorks: Preferred order of flow

Question

question

Ville Teivastenaho asked Feb 24 2023 at 11:21 AM Ville Teivastenaho commented Mar 07 2023 at 12:25 PM

FloWorks: Preferred order of flow

Hi,

I have a problem with a model using the FloWorks module, or I'm not fulling understanding how the flows through the network are being calucated. Attached there is a very simplified example that replicates the issue that I have with my model:

Sink has a max inflow rate of 20.

There are two tanks connected to the sink and both have unconstrained flow. First tank is connected to a flow source, but the output flow from the source is closed.

At the start of the simulation run, the first tank has an output rate of 20 to the sink, as it should with the "Preferred order" selected as sink's inflow rule.

When the first tank runs empty, flow starts (rate 20) from the second tank. The output from the source to the first tank is still closed.

So far everything works as I expect it to work. But after some delay the flow from the source to the first tank is opened. So now there is inflow to the first tank, but the flow to the sink is still coming from the second tank, even though the first one should be preferred and it now starts to accumulate content.

So is this how the flows should behave? And if it is, is there some way to force the flows to be recalculated so that the flow would follow the preferred order of tanks after opening the source?

preferred_order_demo.fsm

Software Version:

FlexSim 23.0.2

FloWorks

preferred-order-demo.fsm (38.9 KiB)

· 3

Patrick Zweekhorst commented · Feb 24 2023 at 1:37 PM

Hi @Ville Teivastenaho ,

This indeed looks a bit like a bug. I would have expected the same flow as you are expecting. We will investigate this further and check if it is a bug or something else is going on. @Harald Emsbroek would probably be best to check what is going on here. He is on holiday next week so it might take till after next week till we are sure of it is a bug or not.

If this is stopping you from continuing your model we might be able to think of a work around. Closing and opening the ports of the tank would for example be an option depending on your model. If you want to discuss any possible work around you can also email me with the actual model if that helps (patrick.zweekhorst@talumis.com), or we schedule a short call.

Patrick

0 ·

Ville Teivastenaho Patrick Zweekhorst commented · Feb 24 2023 at 2:41 PM

Thank you, I'll try first if that work around with opening and closing ports would work. If not, I can also build a logic control the flow manually between different tanks. I was hoping to keep this part of the model as simple as possible, as it is anyway just more or less temporary solution for now.

1 ·

Patrick Zweekhorst Ville Teivastenaho commented · Feb 24 2023 at 2:43 PM

Sounds good. Don't hesitate to ask an extra question or some help with the work around! I will definitely let you know when we have some more information about this problem.

0 ·

______

Cookie preferences

Your privacy is important to us and so is an optimal experience. To help us customize information and build applications, we collect data about your use of this site.

May we collect and use your data?

Learn more about the Third Party Services we use and our Privacy Statement.

Strictly necessary – required for our site to work and to provide services to you

These cookies allow us to record your preferences or login information, respond to your requests or fulfill items in your shopping cart.

YES

Improve your experience – allows us to show you what is relevant to you

These cookies enable us to provide enhanced functionality and personalization. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose services we use to deliver information and experiences tailored to you. If you do not allow these cookies, some or all of these services may not be available for you.

YES

NO

Customize your advertising – permits us to offer targeted advertising to you

These cookies collect data about you based on your activities and interests in order to show you relevant ads and to track effectiveness. By collecting this data, the ads you see will be more tailored to your interests. If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted advertising.

YES

NO

Are you sure you want a less customized experience?

We can access your data only if you select "yes" for the categories on the previous screen. This lets us tailor our marketing so that it's more relevant for you. You can change your settings at any time by visiting our privacy statement

Your experience. Your choice.

We care about your privacy. The data we collect helps us understand how you use our products, what information you might be interested in, and what we can improve to make your engagement with Autodesk more rewarding.

May we collect and use your data to tailor your experience?

Explore the benefits of a customized experience by managing your privacy settings for this site or visit our Privacy Statement to learn more about your options.

Answer 1 · 2023-03-07T11:27:20Z

Harald Emsbroek answered Mar 07 2023 at 11:27 AM Ville Teivastenaho commented Mar 07 2023 at 12:25 PM

Hi @Ville Teivastenaho,

I looked at the model, and the flow isn't what you (and I) expected. However, this isn't a bug, but it is by design. Let me explain this.

The solver tries to push as much product through the network as possible. Pushing is being done at the FlowSource, but also at nonempty FlowObjects, like FlowTanks. In this model the tank at the bottom is also pushing product into the network. This means that the FlowSource can push 20 into the network, and the FlowTank at the bottom (Cylindric2) can also push 20 into the network, but only if the 20 from the FlowSource is stored in the FlowTank at the top (Cylindric1), because of the inflow constraint at the FlowSink. So there is a total flow of 40, pushed out of the flow generating objects. This is more than the total of 20 we would have if only the path from the FlowSource to the FlowSink is used.

You can prevent the flow from FlowTank Cylindric2 to the FlowSink by closing the input port of the FlowSink, or the outflow (port) at the FlowTank. Just let us know if you need help with that, or if you need an example.

· 1

question